Rethinking Canada’s Democracy: Time to Drop the Monarchy and Rethink the System?
Canada, oh Canada. Up here we’re known as the land of maple syrup, politeness, and a parliamentary system that might just be more outdated than dial-up internet. Recently, Alberta’s premier, Danielle Smith, proposed a sovereignty referendum for 2026. That’s got Quebec’s Sovereignty Party all fired up again, floating the idea of independence—yes, again. It’s a topic that still lingers in the minds of many Canadians who remember 1995, when it came down to a nail-biting 51 to 49 vote. We barely dodged that breakup. The kids in the back of the car aren’t happy, and frankly, neither are we. Maybe it’s time we get honest about something: this whole system? It’s creaking. And from where I sit out in Victoria, one of the furthest outposts from Ottawa, practically waving at Japan across the Pacific, it feels less like a country and more like a confederation on autopilot.
The housing market has gone feral, inflation’s having a field day, and wages seem to have missed the memo entirely. Meanwhile, we still curtsy to a king most of us couldn’t pick out of a lineup. My Canada includes $5 lettuce, soul-crushing rent, and no real say in a Senate that nobody elected. If we were designing a nation from scratch today, would we seriously copy-paste this structure from the 1800s? Let’s be real. We’d probably opt for something that didn’t treat Western Canada like a remote colony and Indigenous reconciliation like a side hustle.
The Case for Overhauling a Tired System
1. The Senate: Canada’s Least-Visited Tourist Attraction
The Senate is like that vintage tea set your grandmother gave you—it’s pretty, mostly decorative, and no one quite knows what to do with it. These unelected officials wield real legislative power, yet there’s zero public accountability. We’re told they bring “sober second thought,” but let’s be honest here. How many Canadians could name even one senator? This isn’t democracy; it’s a polite oligarchy.
2. The Prime Minister Monopoly on Power
Under majority governments, our Prime Ministers govern like elected monarchs. Whether it’s Trudeau or Diefenbaker, party discipline turns MPs into nodding bobbleheads, rendering Parliament a rubber stamp. The first-past-the-post electoral system doesn’t help either. Parties win majorities with a minority of the vote, leaving millions of Canadians politically homeless. This isn’t just inefficientit’s exclusionary.
3. Western Discontent Isn’t Just a Tantrum
Living in B.C. feels like being on a Wi-Fi network with terrible connection to Ottawadelayed, ignored, and buffering. Alberta’s rage isn’t baseless either; it’s built on decades of underrepresentation and being treated like the nation’s cash cow. A reimagined Senate, one where each province actually has equal say (imagine that!), could prevent the kind of alienation currently boiling over.
Time to Cut the Royal Cord
Canada’s symbolic allegiance to the Crown has gone from charming to cringeworthy. King Charles, bless his climate activism, lives across an ocean and represents a nation we fought to distance ourselves from. Touting ourselves as a progressive, multicultural mosaic while our head of state is chosen by birthright in Buckingham Palace? That’s not post-colonial. It’s cosplay.
Younger Canadians, newcomers, and Indigenous communities increasingly view the monarchy as irrelevant at best, insulting at worst. If we’re serious about truth and reconciliation, then maybe we should stop anchoring our identity to a family that once ruled over us with redcoats and rifles.
But Let’s Not Go Full America, Either
Sure, the U.S. system has elected senators, checks and balances, and an actual separation of powers. But it also comes with congressional gridlock, weaponized partisanship, and election fatigue that makes tax season look relaxing.
Canadians love to joke about American dysfunction, and with good reason. While their system offers more accountability, it’s also a masterclass in legislative paralysis. We need more democracy, not more drama.
A Middle Path for a Middle Power
Canada doesn’t need to set fire to its constitution. It needs to declutter, simplify, and update it. Here’s the pragmatic playbook:
Elect the Senate with equal provincial representation to give all regions a real voice. Ditch first-past-the-post for a voting system that actually reflects the will of the people—ranked ballots, anyone? Create a Canadian Head of State, not a King, but someone selected by merit or democratic vote, not family tree. Clarify federal and provincial roles so we stop stepping on each other’s constitutional toes every budget season.
This isn’t about erasing our past—it’s about making our future work better for everyone, from downtown Toronto to rural Saskatchewan to, yes, even us West Coast weirdos sipping oat milk lattes in Victoria.
Final Thought: We Deserve Better Than Nostalgia
Canada’s current system is like your grandpa’s Buick. Reliable in its day, but now it guzzles gas, handles like a moose on skates, and refuses to start in winter. We need a civic tune-up. Maybe not a whole new engine, but definitely new parts.
Let’s stop pretending that political evolution is betrayal. Real patriotism is wanting your country to be better, smarter, fairer. The Crown won’t save us, and neither will a broken status quo. But maybe, just maybe, we can.
Let’s call it what it is: It’s time Canada grew up.
Josh Nash 
Leave a comment